Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
Probate litigation in Fairfield, Sacramento, and across California has surged in recent years due to increasingly complex family structures, aging populations, contested bequests, and disputes over real property. When a will is disputed, an executor fails to perform, or assets were mishandled before or after death, beneficiaries often require decisive legal action.
1. Understanding Probate Litigation in California
Probate litigation refers to any contested matter in the administration of a decedent’s estate, typically involving disputes about the validity of a will, the conduct of a personal representative, or the distribution of estate assets.
Common Probate Litigation Issues
- Contested wills
- Executor or administrator misconduct
- Challenges to asset distributions
- Disputes involving omitted heirs or spouses
- Real property conflicts
- Breach of fiduciary duty
- Creditor claim disputes
- Failure to account
- Recovery of property wrongfully taken before death
- Spousal election and family property disputes
Probate litigation often intersects with trust litigation, elder financial abuse, and fiduciary breach claims.
2. When Probate Litigation Becomes Necessary
California probate is not inherently adversarial, but litigation becomes unavoidable when:
- A will appears forged or altered
- A caretaker or relative exerted undue influence
- The decedent lacked capacity when the will was executed
- The executor refuses to communicate or account
- Real estate is sold improperly or below market
- Assets are missing or were transferred suspiciously
- One beneficiary receives preferential treatment
- An omitted spouse or child asserts rights
Our firm evaluates the merits, develops factual timelines, and initiates strategic actions to protect the estate and beneficiaries.
3. Grounds for Contesting a Will in California
Will contests must be based on recognized legal grounds. The most common include:
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
The testator must understand the nature of signing a will, their property, and their natural heirs.
Undue Influence
Occurs when someone pressures or manipulates a vulnerable person into changing a will.
Fraud
Misrepresentations or deceit used to induce changes or hide material facts.
Duress or Coercion
Threats or force affecting the decedent’s free will.
Forgery
A will or signature altered or created by someone other than the testator.
Mistake or Ambiguity
Provisions unclear, contradictory, or contrary to the decedent’s intent.
Will contests must be filed timely—often before the will is admitted to probate or shortly thereafter.
4. Executor and Administrator Duties Under California Probate Law
Personal representatives (executors or administrators) owe strict fiduciary duties under the Probate Code.
Core Duties Include:
- Collecting and safeguarding estate assets
- Inventorying and appraising property
- Paying valid debts and taxes
- Maintaining accurate records
- Serving statutory notices
- Filing required accountings
- Acting impartially toward all beneficiaries
- Distributing assets according to the will or intestacy laws
When an executor breaches these duties, court intervention is warranted.
5. Signs of Executor Misconduct
Beneficiaries should be alert to red flags such as:
- Failure to communicate or provide transparency
- Delays in opening probate or filing documents
- Missing personal property or unexplained withdrawals
- Refusal to provide accountings
- Selling real estate without notice or below market
- Commingling estate funds with personal accounts
- Preferential treatment of certain beneficiaries
- Payments to friends, relatives, or business associates
- Ignoring creditor claims or tax obligations
Executor misconduct can cause substantial financial harm to the estate.
6. Beneficiary Rights in Probate Litigation
Heirs and beneficiaries have enforceable rights, including the right to:
- Receive notices of probate filings
- Review and challenge accountings
- Object to improper distributions
- Petition for executor removal
- Assert inheritance or statutory shares
- Contest a will
- Seek recovery of assets improperly transferred
- Demand court oversight of administration
Our firm ensures beneficiaries receive full protection under the Probate Code.
7. Common Types of Probate Litigation We Handle
Will Contests
We challenge or defend wills based on undue influence, lack of capacity, fraud, or forgery.
Executor Removal and Suspension
Executors can be removed for:
- Breach of fiduciary duty
- Failure to administer the estate
- Mismanagement
- Conflicts of interest
- Conviction of certain crimes
- Incapacity or neglect
We file petitions for suspension, removal, or appointment of a neutral professional fiduciary when necessary.
Accounting Disputes
Statutory accountings must be accurate, supported, and compliant. We litigate objections involving:
- Missing assets
- Inflated expenses
- Improper fees
- Undisclosed transactions
- Unauthorized payments
Real Property Disputes
Frequently litigated issues include:
- Occupancy disputes
- Unauthorized sales
- Title disagreements
- Partition actions
- Valuation conflicts
Omitted Heir / Omitted Spouse Claims
California law protects family members unintentionally excluded from a will.
Creditor Claim Litigation
We prosecute and defend challenges to creditor claims, including medical bills, loans, and secured debts.
Pre-Death Asset Recovery
If someone wrongfully took funds or property before the decedent’s death, litigation may recover those assets into the estate.
8. How Elder Abuse and Undue Influence Intersect with Probate Litigation
Many probate disputes directly stem from financial elder abuse, particularly when:
- A caregiver pressured the decedent to change a will
- A relative gained signature authority late in life
- Real estate was transferred shortly before death
- The elder was isolated or cognitively impaired
California law (EADACPA) provides enhanced remedies, including:
- Asset recovery
- Attorney’s fees
- Pain-and-suffering damages in qualifying cases
- Punitive damages
We frequently litigate cases involving undue influence and elder exploitation within a probate framework.
9. Remedies Available in Probate Litigation
Executor Removal
For misconduct, incapacity, or breach of duty.
Surcharge and Repayment Orders
Personal liability for financial losses caused by an executor.
Compelled Accountings
Court-ordered transparent reporting.
Return of Estate Property
Recovery of assets wrongfully taken before or during probate.
Injunctions
To stop sales, freeze accounts, or protect real estate.
Declaratory Relief
Clarifying ambiguous will provisions.
Distribution Orders
Enforcing proper distribution of estate assets.
Appointment of Professional Fiduciaries
When a neutral party is needed to stabilize administration.
10. Our Firm’s Approach to Probate Litigation
Step 1: Rapid Fact Development
We gather documents, accountings, bank statements, medical records, correspondence, and witness statements.
Step 2: Strategic Petition Practice
We file the correct petitions—removal, accounting, surcharge, contest, injunction—based on the situation.
Step 3: Emergency Relief
When assets are at risk, we pursue immediate suspensions, freezes, and restraining orders.
Step 4: Evidence-Based Negotiation
Strong documentary proof is the key driver of favorable settlements in probate litigation.
Step 5: Trial-Ready Posture
We prepare each matter as if trial will occur, ensuring maximum leverage.
Step 6: Enforcement
If orders are ignored, we pursue contempt, surcharge enforcement, and post-judgment collection.
11. Why Clients in Sacramento and Solano County Choose Our Probate Litigation Firm
- Deep knowledge of Sacramento County and Solano County probate courts
- Decisive handling of executor misconduct
- Extensive experience with will contests and pre-death asset recovery
- Integrated knowledge of trust law and elder abuse law
- A disciplined, evidence-focused litigation strategy
- Clear and candid assessment of likely outcomes
We represent heirs, beneficiaries, executors, administrators, creditors, and omitted family members.
12. Frequently Asked Questions About Probate Litigation
How long do I have to contest a will?
A will contest must generally be filed before the will is admitted to probate or within a narrow window afterward.
Can an executor be held personally liable?
Yes. Executors can be surcharged for mismanagement or breach of duty.
What if property was taken before death?
A Probate Code § 850 petition can recover pre-death transfers.
Can I stop the sale of estate property?
Yes. Injunctions or temporary restraining orders can halt unauthorized sales.
Do I need an attorney to object to an accounting?
Given statutory complexity and evidentiary burdens, professional representation is essential.
13. Contact a Local Sacramento and Solano County Probate Litigation Attorney
If you are facing a probate dispute, suspect executor misconduct, or need to contest a will, early legal action is crucial. Delays can destroy evidence and limit your remedies.
Schedule a confidential consultation with a Sacramento and Fairfield probate litigation attorney today.
